Contact Us Today

Office: (858) 272-3900
Stay Connected With Us:
YouTube Twitter Facebook Pinterest google

Old Town San Diego Property Management

We can Help Manage Your Old Town San Diego Rental Property

Old Town San Diego Property Management

Penny Realty, Inc. has been an established leader in Single Family Home and Multifamily Property Management since 1965. We recognize that your rental property is a very valuable asset. You can entrust the management of that asset to an organization with a long trusted history that offers you piece of mind. We customize our service based on the owner and property needs. Our portfolio is composed of single-family homes and multi-family dwellings up to 100 units. We guarantee we will rent your property in 14 Days or less. On average, Penny Realty rents vacant Homes and Condos in 11 days from the time they are rent ready. Please Click Here to learn about our Exclusive 5 step Marketing Plan. Not only do we rent fast, but we also rent to high quality residents. Please see the Penny Realty exclusive 11 step resident Screening process.

If you would like to see how we stack up against other San Diego Property Management Companies, see our Comparison Chart.

Single Family Old Town San Diego Property Management

Penny Realty, Inc.’s team is made up of Property Managers, Leasing Agents, Bookkeepers and Maintenance Personnel who execute the delicate management of relationships between residents and owners. We have deep experience and knowledge in adhering to the best practices in the Property Management Industry. This means you are assured of protecting the value of your real estate asset and increasing your equity and long term return on your investment. We also create a friendly environment for residents in which they enjoy over the top customer service and prompt response to their daily living needs.

  • Penny Realty Inc. offers fee based management services.
  • Our Corporate office is located in central San Diego, more specifically, Pacific Beach. We manage properties throughout all of San Diego County.
  • Penny Realty, Inc. offers a consistent approach to Property Management that helps us provide the quality service that our clients require. However, we are flexible enough to fit your needs and offer customized Property Management solutions.


We manage all financial aspects of owning and Rental Income property.

  • Monthly Owner Statements & Disbursements
  • Rent Collection
  • Insurance and Property Tax Payments
  • Reoccurring and Single Expense Payments related to your property
  • Electronic Financial Reports
  • Owner Portal containing archived reports
  • Direct Deposit of owner proceeds or paid by check
  • Debt Collection Services


  • We advertise upcoming and current vacancies daily on multiple websites as well as the San Diego Multiple Listing Service.
  • We know how to obtain maximum exposure for your vacant rental. Our objective is to obtain the maximum amount of fair market rent in the shortest period of time possible.
  • An up to date available property listing can be found in our lobby at all times.
  • Our Penny Realty, Inc. signs are posted on our nearly 350 properties.

Fair Housing Laws+

  • It is essential to adhere to all Federal and State Fair housing Laws.
  • Our team is well versed in Fair Housing Laws which avoids unnecessary liability to the owner.

Expense Reductions+

  • We have an extensive list of preferred vendors who offer reduced rates due to the high volume of business they receive from Penny Realty, Inc. We use only well vetted, insured vendors with a track record of success.
  • Our attention to detail during move in and move out inspections allow the recovery of turnover costs through Security Deposit deductions.
  • We require all residents to carry a Limited Liability Renter’s Insurance Policy that provides minimum of $100,000 in Liability Insurance.

Inquire About Our Services

Top 5 Mistakes Landlords Make

What Clients Are Saying About Us

Multi Family Old Town San Diego Property Management

Since 1965, we have been successfully helping clients reposition and improve their Multi-Family properties. We are also skilled and experienced in complex 1031 tax deferred sales. The following are areas we can assist our owners:

Professional Affiliations+

  • San Diego Convention and Visitors Bureau
  • Better Business Bureau (A+ Rating!)
  • National Association of Residential Property Managers (NARPM)
  • Vacation Rental Manager Association (VRMA)
  • Institute for Luxury Home Marketing (ILHM)
  • California Association of Realtors (CAR)
  • San Diego Association of Realtors (SDAR)

The Penny Realty Difference

Don’t just hire a property management company… Hire a strategic business partner that is dedicated to improving the bottom line results of your investment real estate… and take confidence in our guarantee’s to you. They represent “best in class” in the property management business!

We understand that your Rental Property is your “pride and joy” and represents a substantial investment. Not only does Penny Realty take extraordinary steps to maximize your revenue and net income, but we also go above and beyond to protect your property.

14 Day Rental Guarantee

If we are unable to lease your Home in 14 Days or less, we will provide your first TWO months of property management free!

Conditions for the 14 Day Guarantee:

  • We must set the price based on our knowledge of fair rental value.
  • The Home or Condo must be vacant.
  • The 14 Days start when the Home is ready and in move-in condition.
  • The 14 Day Rental Guarantee is not offered to everyone. It must be part of, and written into your property management agreement.

Results Guarantee

With our results guarantee you don’t pay us any money until we produce! You can look at us as your junior partner, who happens to be an expert in the property management business. We get paid when you get paid!

  • We do all the work up front and you don’t pay us until the residents start paying rent.
  • We will launch a full marketing campaign, show your property, thoroughly screen the residents, draft the lease, and perform a move-in inspection… all with no upfront fees!
  • We do not charge a leasing fee and there is no mark-up on maintenance services.
  • There is no charge for set-up fees, admin fees, and transfer fees. There is just one fair full service fee that starts when your resident starts paying rent.
  • Our “Results Guarantee” assures you that we will work hard on your behalf and provide you with positive results and peace of mind!

Eviction Free Guarantee

At Penny Realty we take great pride in the selection of high quality residents. Due to our high standards we are able to provide an “Eviction Free Guarantee”.

If a resident needs to be evicted for non-payment of rent, our legal counsel will handle the eviction up to $1,200. Additionally, we will re-rent the property with zero leasing fees.

Conditions for the Eviction Free Guarantee:

  • We must have placed the resident. This does not cover residents we have taken over or inherited.
  • This guarantee is only for eviction due to non-payment of rent.
  • We must be the Property Manager for the entire length of tenancy.
  • This offer does not cover the cost of the resident attorney fees or related expenses.

The Eviction Free Guarantee is not offered to everyone. It must be specifically included in your property management agreement.

We strive to align our interests with yours so that we act in your best interest. Our goals are as follows:

Old Town San Diego Area Information

Old Town San Diego Property Managers

Old Town San Diego was California’s first settlement in 1769 with only a mission and fort. It is now the historic heart of San Diego and features 12 acres of Mexican heritage and historical sites, colorful shops, early-California style museums and authentic Mexican cuisine. Pause to reflect at the fountains at Fiesta de Reyes and in the Bazaar del Mundo, plan a day or two to visit the dozens of historic sites, or take a tour of the Whaley haunted house, one of the most haunted houses in the US. Old Town San Diego is a robust community consisting of four major parks: Old Town San Diego Historic Park, Old Town Victorian Heritage Park, a city of San Diego Whaley House Park and city-owned Serra Museum and grounds. There are a variety of beautiful historical homes that offer plenty of charm and amazing views of San Diego and the Bay.

Click here to see areas we serve

Have a Question or Need More Information? Contact Us

BBB SDAR CAR Equal Housing
Excellance ReCogn ILHN Best Property Managers in San Diego

Copyright © 20202020 Penny Realty, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Property Management Website powered by | Sitemap

Our Office
4444 Mission Blvd.
San Diego, CA 92109
Cal BRE #00935682

Office: (858) 272-3900
Fax: (858) 272-9087
Emergencies: (858) 692-0181